Carson Palmer will be an Oakland Raider by the end of the day. The Raiders send a 2012 1st round pick as well as a conditional 1st round pick in 2013. That is a very steep price for a player who has not been the same since his serious knee injury versus Pittsburgh in the playoffs in the 2005-2006 season. He’s definitely a quality quarterback, but in my opinion he is a pretty significant risk considering how he has played since his injury and because of how long it has been since he played a snap in a NFL game. How long will it be until he is ready to play? Will the Raiders still be in position to compete for a playoff spot? Will Palmer be able to mesh with the Raiders’ current personnel in time to lead them to the playoffs?
These are all questions that I find myself asking and honestly I have my doubts. Stranger things have happened, but it’s tough for a new quarterback to acclimate himself to a new roster when he is signed as a free agent and has an entire offseason, much less being traded to them mid-season when he has been previously out of football for the entire season. He has to mesh with the roster, learn and then master the playbook, and then go out there and make plays on Sundays. That’s a lot to ask of anyone, but it will be interesting to see if Palmer is up to the task. I have to say I am pretty skeptical just because it is a very tall order, but if he can pick up the playbook quickly and is embraced by the locker room then he has a chance to lead the Raiders to the playoffs. I have to say, as a fan I am excited about the potential of this move and I am very interested to see if Palmer can make this worthwhile for the Raiders. The early winner of this trade is clearly the Bengals in my opinion. Potentially getting two first round picks for a player who was never going to start for you again thanks to Dalton’s emergence as a quality leader? Yeah, that’s a pretty nice trade. Plus they are off the hook for his salary of which there was nearly $20 million remaining over the next two years.
I love the boldness of this move, I just question whether or not I would have done the same. That’s an awfully high asking price, and this potential batch of quarterbacks in the 2012 NFL Draft class figures to be significantly better than any of the recent QB draft classes as far as overall talent and depth. But you have to think that if Al Davis was still running things this would be the kind of move he would make: It may seem crazy to some people, but he trusted his evaluation of the move as well as the rest of his staff and he believed that his coaches could make the most out of the acquisition. So in a way, this is kind of like Al’s last bold move as a Raider. I for one am rooting for them, and hopefully Palmer can find a way to make an immediate and lasting impact in Oakland.